Hindu Vivek Kendra
A RESOURCE CENTER FOR THE PROMOTION OF HINDUTVA
   
 
 
«« Back
 

People question why this French publication has peddled two misleading reports on Rafale till now

Author: OpIndia Staff
Publication: Opindia.com
Date: October 11, 2018
URL:      https://www.opindia.com/2018/10/people-question-why-this-french-publication-has-peddled-two-misleading-reports-on-rafale-till-now/amp/?__twitter_impression=true

French publication Mediapart has till now published two misleading reports on the Rafale deal. First one came when it published a quote by former French President Hollande where he reportedly had said that the Government of India had proposed that the Anil Ambani owned Reliance Defence should be the service provider to Dassault in the mega-deal. As the controversy escalated, the French government issued a statement that the contract between the French and the Indian government was strictly related to the delivery and quantity of the aircraft. It further clarified that the French government had no role to play in the choice of Indian industrial partners and French companies have the full freedom to choose the Indian company they want to partner with.

OpIndia had then reported how the facts of the deal are being selectively ignored by the politicians to score a political point. We had explained how as per the offset obligations put by India, Dassault would have to fulfil offset obligations of 50% of total deal value in the forms of investment in India, purchase from India, or transfer of technology to Indian companies. As per the offset agreement, Dassault got into contracts with hundreds of companies including Anil Ambani led Reliance as well as state-owned Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL).

Despite the clarifications, in less than a month, Mediapart again came up with another misleading report which claimed that deal with Reliance was mandatory for Dassault. The report quoted Deputy Chief Executive Officer of Dassault Aviation Loik Segalen to have said, “It was imperative and mandatory for Dassault Aviation to accept this counterpart (offset partnership), in order to seal the deal to sell Rafale jet to India.” The quote appears to have been mischievously quoted since Dassault again had to reiterate though a statement that as Segalen said, it was indeed ‘imperative and mandatory’ for Dassault to accept the offset partnership, nowhere does it mention the offset partner has to be Reliance. In fact, as per French labour laws, any major decision taken by companies which may not lead to new employment generation for French workers, need to be informed to Central Works Council. The above statement by Segalen appears more of a message to the representatives of the union who were present there instead of an insinuation that they were arm-twisted into getting into a contract with Reliance for the contract.

This repeated misleading reports by the French media Mediapart, which were picked up and shared widely by various mainstream media as well as Congress leaders, made a lot of Twitter users wonder about the ulterior motives of the reports. Twitter user @bns5, in a series of tweets, showed how the owner of Mediapart, when the report came out last night, had reached out to certain individuals to spread the message.
................................................................................
Edwy Plenel @edwyplenel
 Dear colleagues, new revelations on @Mediapart about the #RafaleDeal. English version is coming soon. @IndiaToday @ndtv @vikramchandra @svaradarajan @thewire_in

Edwy Plenel @edwyplenel
[BREAKING NEWS] Affaire des #Rafale en Inde: un document interne au groupe Dassault obtenu par @Mediapart montre que la France considérait l'alliance avec Reliance comme une «contrepartie» «impérative et obligatoire» pour obtenir le marché. #RafaleDeal https://www.mediapart.fr/journal/international/101018/affaire-des-rafale-en-inde-un-nouveau-document-accable-dassault?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=Sharing&xtor=CS3-67 …
9:47 PM - Oct 10, 2018
................................................................................

He says that as soon as the article by Mediapart was out, the first one to share it was Noopur Tiwari of NDTV.
................................................................................
Narayan @bns5
Oct 11, 2018
Replying to @bns5
Hmmm......
Is this ( #RafalePropaganda ) a joint venture between ndtv & mediapart ? pic.twitter.com/6zfR2QnygQ

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DpK0TWYX4AcC5-D.jpg

Narayan @bns5
MediaPart tweets on #RafalePropaganda and guess who was first to tag it within 5 minutues ? No prizes for guessing ...... pic.twitter.com/0erzeg7zh3
12:41 AM - Oct 11, 2018

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DpK1yQbWkAEn1C0.jpg

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DpK1zifXUAQG_m8.jpg
................................................................................

An article on Plenel from April 2013 quotes a senior French radio journalist describing Plenel as, “vigilante not a journalist…someone who confuses journalism with personal vendettas and crusades.” His former colleagues at Le Monde, where he was an editor once, describe him as ‘tyrant’ and ‘bully’.

In March this year, Naëm Bestandji, a secular feminist activist, has accused Plenel of becoming a groupie of Marwan Muhammad, former director of Collective against Islamophobia in France, CCIF, who according to Bestandji, discriminates against people like him, (French of Maghrebi origin) and insults them in the name of ‘tolerance and anti-racism.’

This brings us to how and why are the mainstream media persons and Congress leaders so quick to believe a white man who seems to be having questionable credentials?
 
«« Back
 
 
 
  Search Articles
 
  Special Annoucements