Hindu Vivek Kendra
A RESOURCE CENTER FOR THE PROMOTION OF HINDUTVA
   
 
 
«« Back
Islam in an Indian environment

Islam in an Indian environment

Author: Sushil Chaudhury
Publication: The Sunday Statesman
Date: January 28, 2001
 
Islam has been continuously redefined, reinterpreted and contested over the last fifteen centuries, as competing social groups have risen or fallen in prominence and influence. Hence the challenge for the historian is to identify these groups, and by situating them in their unique historical context, to determine how they constructed the religion in the particular way they did. It is heartening that Richard M Eaton, an acknowledged authority on Indian Islam, has tried to answer the challenge successfully and with rare competence in the present volume which is a collection of eleven essays written over the years and published in different journals and anthologies. He has tried to explain how and why the Perso-Islamic encounter with India gave rise to such cultural florescence, greater than even the Arab-Islamic encounter with Europe. And also, how can one explain the extraordinary uneven distribution of Muslims in South Asia?

The essays in the present volume address these and related issues and are subdivided into two categories: historiographical essays which examine how historians structure and answer the questions they choose to ask of the past, and case studies on the history of particular Indian communities. In these essays there is a concern, explicit or implicit, with the dynamics of metropolis-frontier relations. For example, the religious demography of South Asia shows that Islam took root much more readily in Bengal or the Punjab, than in Upper India, the area with the deepest tradition of Indo-Muslim rule and patronage. The essays also challenge the image of Islam as a fixed or monolithic essence.

An attempt has been made in the first group of five essays to place the study of Islam and Indian history in a larger historical framework. The last essay in this group shifts the historical focus to recent scholarly trends in the analysis of Indian history, with particular reference to subaltern studies, and tries to explain how the destruction of Babri Masjid affected what subalternists, post-modernist and post-colonialist historians thought about the history of pre-modern India. The next group of essays in Part Two deal with case studies that explore 'permutations' of Islamic history and society in three South Asian regions - the Deccan, Punjab and Bengal.

Though most of the essays in this collection are quite interesting and illuminating, the two that are of considerable importance are Chapter 4, 'Temple Destruction and Indo-Muslim States' and Chapter 11, "Who are the Bengal Muslims: Conversion and Islamisation in Bengal". The first one is a timely topic, especially in the backdrop of the destruction of the Babri Masjid. It tries to examine the available evidence of temple desecration and in the process asks such questions as, what temples were desecrated in India's pre-modern history, when and by whom, how and for what purpose, and finally, in this context, to find out the relationship between religion and politics in pre-modern India. Significantly, Eaton holds that it is through selective translations of Persian chronicles along with a selective use of epigraphic data that the Hindu "nationalists" have sought to find the sort of "irrefutable" evidence that would demonstrate a persistent pattern of villainy and fanaticism among the Indo-Muslim conquerors and rulers.

He suggests that the original data associate instances of temple desecration - he has identified 80 such instances whose "historicity appears certain" in the five centuries between the 12th and 18th, as opposed to 60,000 claimed by some Hindu nationalists' - with the annexation of newly conquered territories held by enemy kings whose domains lay on the path of moving military frontiers. Desecration of temples also took place when Hindu patrons of prominent temples were associated with acts of treason or disloyalty (as in the case of Viswanath temple at Benares whose patron Jai Singh was suspected of treason and the Kesava temple at Mathura which was destroyed following a Jat rebellion, both during the reign of Aurangzeb). Otherwise temples lying within Indo-Muslim sovereign domains, viewed normally as protected state property, were left unmolested.

The last essay in the book examines the evolution of Bengal Muslims between the 16th and 18th centuries, and explores why and how Islam became the dominant religious tradition in Bengal, and not in upper India, the epicentre of Indo-Muslim political culture, and in, the eastern, not western, part of the Bengal delta. In this context it is interesting to note that unlike early Sultans of Bengal, Mughal officials did not patronise Islam as a state religion. The Mughals maintained a strictly non-interventionist position in religious matters, despite pressure from local mullahs and sufis. One consequence of this hands-off policy was that Mughal officials refused to promote the conversion of Bengalis to Islam. But the paradox is that although Muslim regimes had ruled over Bengal since the early 13th century, a noticeable community of Muslim peasants did not emerge there until the late 16th century, and that too under a regime, that did nothing to encourage conversion. What made this possible was that in the Mughal period, Bengal's agrarian and political frontiers coalesced into one. This was achieved by land grants by the state aiming at the agricultural development of forested hinterland, most of whose recipients were petty mullahs, pilgrims returned from Mecca, charismatic pirs, etc. These men oversaw, or undertook to oversee, the clearing of forests and construction of mosques or shrines, which in turn became the nuclei for the diffusion of Islamic religion and ideals along the frontier. Above all, the local communities that fell under the economic and religious influence of these institutions do not appear to have perceived Islam as alien because it absorbed so much local culture and became so profoundly identified with the delta's long-term process of agrarian expansion.
 


Back                          Top

«« Back
 
 
 
  Search Articles
 
  Special Annoucements