Hindu Vivek Kendra
A RESOURCE CENTER FOR THE PROMOTION OF HINDUTVA
   
 
 
«« Back
Rumour and superstition make fight against polio falter in Aligarh

Rumour and superstition make fight against polio falter in Aligarh

Author: M V R Rao
Publication: The Indian Express
Date: May 29, 2003
URL: http://www.indianexpress.com/archive_full_story.php?content_id=24763

* Eighteen-month-old Nazneen, daughter of a poor rickshaw- puller, had barely learnt to crawl when her limbs went limp. Struck by polio, she is now crippled for life and won't walk ever again.

* Gabbar Khan, six months older to Naznin, shares her fate. He will never stand erect on his legs again. Polio struck him a few months back.

More and more children in Aligarh district are ending up with twisted limbs as organisations like the WHO, UNICEF and Rotary International and the district authorities find that their concerted campaign against the disease is proving to be hopelessly inadequate.

By last weekend, 10 children had made it to this year's list, and Monday brought more bad news. Nihal Syed of Upar Kot mohalla joined the mounting statistics. And all these children are Muslims. District chief medical officer Dr M P Bansal is quite worried.

Going by population density West Bengal's 24 Parganas South with 12 cases is worst but this is bad enough. And seven of these cases are from urban areas. (UP with 27 and Bengal with 23 have also reported the highest number of polio cases out of a cumulative total of 81 detected in the country so far. In 2002, Azamgarh had reported 81 cases which was the highest among districts.) Chief Minister Mayawati has warned all district magistrates that this could be their waterloo even as they get ready for the next round of Pulse Polio this Sunday.

Influential community members have been roped in. Prominent among them is Aligarh Muslim University's IAS officer-turned-Vice Chancellor Dr Naseem Ahmed. He has been visiting the Jama Masjids in Aligarh and other Muslim- dominated, vulnerable towns like Moradabad and Azamgarh and speaking to the devout after 'Jummey ki namaaz' which ensures large congregations. He has roped in the entire university staff in this effort, perhaps, embarrassed by this alarming turn of events in the university's backyard.

Despite an ad blitz on television, religious prejudices, rumours and conspiracy theories are proving to be more potent than the polio drops. Most people fear that the drops may cause impotency and quacks and vested interests are fanning fears. Ulsan, a mother of five children, says she first gave the drops to her kids. ''Par jab yeh kaha jaaney laga ki issay namardi ho jayegi, mainey dawa pilani band kar di,'' she told The Indian Express. Later she saw reason and returned but that's not true in most cases.
 

In areas like Bhojpura and Jeevangarh, the campaign is seen to be a saffron ploy to control and then decimate the Muslims. At a roadside tea-stall, Irfan and others even blamed it all on ''Amrika ki saazish'' (US conspiracy).

Dr Hanif Ahmed Khan, a medical practitioner who coordinates the campaign in the high-risk Jeevangarh area, says they even point out that the ''gora sahibs'' and ''gori mems'' (officials of the WHO and NGOs) come so often only to implement their ''diabolical designs''.

Pulse polio volunteers run the risk of being beaten up. CMO Dr Bansal says there are still 1,500 houses in different areas where they simply refused to listen.

Health workers Riazuddin and Farah in Bhojpura say they lock up their houses and send their children away. Dr Khan says many even confront them with ''Nahin pilatey, hamari marzi, koi zabardasti hai kya?'' (We won't give the drops, will you force us?''

Aggressive residents know how to put the medical teams on the defensive. ''Why do you keep coming back for polio drops? What about other diseases?'' they ask, with a dash of some genuine grievances. ''Have you provided us with basic sanitation and medicare,'' they demand.

Dr Athar Ansari of the local J N Medical College's community medicine department points out that the coliform count (faecal contamination) of water in most slum areas is as high as 180 MPN/100 ml against the ''tolerable limit'' of 10. ''Running a vertical programme in isolation without providing basic amenities cannot succeed,'' he insists.

High-risk areas like Bhujpura, Jeevangarh and Shahjamal are situated virtually on garbage dumps. One infected kid relieving himself in the open tends to spread the infection.

A high rate of illiteracy, lack of health consciousness and hygience and poverty spells doom for the Muslim-dominated areas from where most cases have been reported, says Dr Tabassum Shahab of the Department of Paediatrics at J N Medical College.

Take the case of two-year-old Gabbar whose grandfather, Mumtaz Netaji, runs a dairy at his house in this thickly congested area. He was administered the drops only once or twice and couldn't keep polio away. Today, his grandfather, along with his wife, Khatun, no longer says it's ''Allah ki marzi'' (It's God's wish). He is trying to motivate his community.

According to Dr Tabassum Shahab, Muslims accounted for 70 per cent of the polio cases in 2001. Last year the figure declined to 58, but this year it has already risen to 80.

Officials must share part of the blame. In most urban areas, the micro plan for coverage was incomplete and some areas and houses were left out in Shahzamal, Upar Kot, Bhujpura and Lodha.

Untrained volunteers compounded the problem. Sources say that in some cases the cold chain was broken because of poor storage and refrigeration problems, aggravated by power cuts. Experts say the numbers could be just the tip of the iceberg as polio case occur in large numbers from June onwards.

'The 2002 polio epidemic had forced the states to gear up. The main issue now is to translate all the preparedness into accountability. The virus is alive and kicking and if we there are any lacunae in the June pulse polio programme, the situation can turn grave,'' said Dr Sobhan Sarkar, deputy commissioner, child health, and In-charge of Polio Eradication, Ministry of Health.
 


Back                          Top

«« Back
 
 
 
  Search Articles
 
  Special Annoucements